AB: Navamsha query

[che]

Hello AB,

I did not want to mes up the other thread, so thought to open up a new one...

let me try to break down what i am trying to ask you again..i hope my query would be clear after this ..

I am asking a query on the importance given to the varga charts esp navamsha...this stemmed from reading your imp of navamsha write up...

a) The rasi chart shows the actual physical representation of planets during a person's birth.

b) The rasi chart is the only physical reality hence.

c) Astrology is a mathematical model which is applied to this physical reality of planetary positions. So rasi chart is basically the application of this mathematical model aka astrology and configuring it by its principles..but still it is the only physical reality.

d) The varga charts are derived mathematcally from this physical rasi chart.

e) The same mathematical model aka Astrology is applied on this derived mathematical models aka varga charts...

f) BUT WHY IS MORE OR EQUAL IMP GIVEN WHEN VARGA CHARTS ARE DERIVATIVES OF RASI CHART ONLY?

RASI SHOULD BE PREDOMINANT IN RANKING RIGHT : A MATHEMATICAL MODEL ON A PHYSICAL REALITY WILL BE MORE IMP THAN A MATHEMATICAL MODEL ON SUPPLEMENTARY MATHEMATICAL DERIVATIVES....

now i do not know how to put this simpler....

SK,RVR,Shilpa and others also please feel free to share your opinion and views....

thanks and regards,