What is the luckiest phase of your life ?

[chavitarun]

respected shilpaji
namaskar

1 it is often written in astro books that dasha of Lagnesh, 5th & 9th house gives good results
even their lords are natural malefics

2. whether dasha of lords of 1, 5 & 9 give good result even if they are posited in dusthana or otherwise
weak or have malefic influence.

in many books only 1st point is written in general description but what about second point

regards

[shilpa]

i have one confusion about combustion of venus , the difference between sun & venus is about 8 to 9 degrees. i read somewhere that combustion happens only upto 3 degrees within sun.
pl. clear my doubt.

venus gets combusted within 12 degrees ( or maybe 13) of Sun....but they have to be in the same house.

the confusion part comes when people try to break it down to percentage (%) partial combustion.

1)for example some people say Venus 9 degree apart from sun will be only 25% combusted.

2)other's say there is nothing like % combustion...once within the combustible range....that planet is SIMPLY combust.

I am personally more aligned with the 2nd, because it makes more astrological sense and I haven't see any supporting evidence to the first.

regards
regards

[chavitarun]

i have one confusion about combustion of venus , the difference between sun & venus is about 8 to 9 degrees. i read somewhere that combustion happens only upto 3 degrees within sun.
pl. clear my doubt.

venus gets combusted within 12 degrees ( or maybe 13) of Sun....but they have to be in the same house.

the confusion part comes when people try to break it down to percentage (%) partial combustion.

1)for example some people say Venus 9 degree apart from sun will be only 25% combusted.

2)other's say there is nothing like % combustion...once within the combustible range....that planet is SIMPLY combust.

I am personally more aligned with the 2nd, because it makes more astrological sense and I haven't see any supporting evidence to the first.

regards
regards

shilpaji
namaskar

This is a article appering on a astro site , your esteemed views are required
Any planet which stays ¬¬within +3 or -3 degrees (same nakshtra-pada) of Sun, is said to be combusted (asthangatha). So the benefits due to the other planet (excluding Sun) are totally destroyed. Perhaps Mercury is an exception (many noted astrologers believe this). Example : If Sun is at 125*32’ and if Venus (Sukra) is at any position from 122*32’ to 128*32’, Sukra is asthangatha (combusted) and powerless and can not give any beneficial results to the person. If Mercury is not combusted and is in the same nakshthra (star) but different pada or within +14* to -14* and also in the same Bhava, Budha-Aditya yoga occurs. If Sun and Mercury are in different Bhava or house, then B.A yoga does not occur. I explain these ideas based on examples : (1) Sun is at 204*12’ and Mercury is at 197*18’. The distance between Sun and Mercury is about 7*; they are near. and they are in same houses; so B.A yoga is formed. (2) Sun is at 195*53’ and Mercury is at 175*27; they are in the same house / bhava; the distance is about 20*. Nipuna yoga is formed; this is less powerful. (3) Sun is at 63*; Mercury is at 56*; birth-lagna (ascendant) is at 68*. The Sun and Mercury are in different houses in Rasi chart (Sun is in Gemini and Mercury is in Taurus). But in Bhava chart the Thanu Bhava (First Bhava) is between 53*and 83*; birth-lagna, Sun and Mercury; all the three are in Thanu-Bhava. There is B.A. yoga in Bhava chart and gives beneficial results. There is no B.A. yoga in Rasi chart. So expert-astrologers take Bhava chart into consideration while anlaysing a horoscope and planetary positions, but not simple Rasi chart
regards

[Khoo Hock Leong]

Hi Shilpa and Anilesh

Yes, there was a typing a mistake.

I am born under GMT 7.5 hrs East in 1962. Only in 1st Jan 1983 did Singapore adjusted its GMT to 8 hrs East to be in line with Hong Kong, Perth and Beijing.

Thus if you take Vimottari Dasa from the Moon (and not Ascendant) I indeed was born under Mahadasa Mars and Antardasa Jupiter. Mars would be in the 10th Bhava and Saturn in the 7th Bhava in the Rasi chart. Yes, I do have extremely good family support and very good family environment right up till now even when I am 49 years old. Any other details?

In the Navamsa chart, Mars becomes my 9th Bhava ruler and Jupiter my 5th Bhava ruler, so giving me royal status under Navamsa.

If you take Vimsottari from the Ascendant, my Mahadasa would be Saturn and Antardasa Mercury in the Rasi chart when I was born.

Saturn governs my 5th Bhava (and a Yogakaraka at that) in D-6 and Mercury governs my 9th Bhava in D-6. I am usually fortunate during the periods of Mahadasa Saturn and Antardasa Mercury as well. Problems simply cannot touch me!

In D-8 and D-30, Mercury and Saturn switch places with Saturn ruling my 9th Bhava and Mercury my 5th Bhava. These give me royal status under D-8 and D-30 and I interpret it as I come up tops in my problems - because D-8 and D-30 has something to do with the outcome of your problems. That is how I interpret them. Is that correct?

However, I place more emphasis taking Vimsottari from the Moon (than on the Ascendant) based on the above information, because I am always fortunate regardless of which dasa periods are operating (for Mars and Jupiter influences) but for Saturn and Mercury good effects to occur, their periods must be operating. Any opinions on this?

Thanks.

Warmest Regards
Hock Leong

[shilpa]

Suppose in a chart, Venus has more potential for marriage or child birth...
MD is of SAT, AD is of JUP say.. and both SAT and JUP do not oppose or moderately support/neutral
to marriage/birth

Going by the logic discussed earlier (that MD acts like PM, AD like cabinet minister); why can not marriage/child birth occur in SAT-JUP-VEN? if yes, is it not that ignoring PD misses a vital prediction
as the natural tendency is to predict the native to wait till SAT-VEN comes...(assuming that say SAT-JUP
comes first and SAT-VEN comes much latter)

If not, is there any reason why AD is more important than MD/PD? If you say it is the time window
of operation,..... yes, AD may span more time than PD, but marriage/birth needs just few days
to complete....
---------------------

Dear Mahesh,

when in doubt....go back to BPHS and review the basic Parasari pricniples.

MD and AD lords are deemed to be powerful and acting indepndent of each other according to ground rules.

Now the two periods could be in either constructive, non-constructive or neutral in their overlap.....but they are still indepndent.

from what I undertsand PD and lower divisions do not have an independent acting status that AD has.

regards

[shilpa]

Does combustion weaken like any other weakness or it preferably affects only karakatwa or houses owned/placed/aspected by combust planet?

I am certain combustion is bad phenomenon for the native.

In my view ( and I am still reseraching this subject) combsution destroys the material signifciations of the house it imapcts and the emotional / abstract karkatwas of the planet.
it leaves intact the general phsyical / material karkatwas of the planet.....again as I said, i am still looking for more and more case studies of combustion to be able to confirm this POV defnitively.


-------------------
3) Some Rajayogas involve mutual placements of planets... whereas basics say a planet causes influence
on another only by aspects...
For example Gajakesari... I remember right, JUP, Moon should be in angular position...
Suppose JUP is in in 1, Moon is in 4; how this yoga works? as JUP/Moon do not cause any influence on each other by aspect/conjuction

all Rajyogas.....are formed in my undertsanding by one of following:
1. Conjuntion
2. Mutual aspect
3. Mutual kendra

Mutual excahge of houses is also a Yoga...a Parivartan Yoga but not a Rajyoga

[shilpa]

when in doubt....go back to BPHS and review the basic Parasari pricniples.

MD and AD lords are deemed to be powerful and acting indepndent of each other according to ground rules.

Yes, basics are clear... I was under the impression that the concept of MD-AD-PD-SD + Transits is basically designed to narrow down the timings, layer by layer systematically. Like for long range projects spaning several years, use MD, for medium range time projects use AD etc. If that is the case, even PD (say 2 moths) should ne independently able to deliver the goods for things like marriage etc...

the fundamental diffrence being...PD is a smaller time portion of AD, subservient to it and carrying it's overall charcteristics
whisch is not the same relation between MD and AD....the latter being a standalone period with it's own disticnt charcetristics



2)

all Rajyogas.....are formed in my undertsanding by one of following:
1. Conjuntion
2. Mutual aspect
3. Mutual kendra

Case 3) shows if A is in 1 and B is in 4 OR one is in 10 other in 1; this is possible, but that does not
necessiate causing influence on each other by aspects... If no mutual influence, still how yoga
can work?

because from what I remember the guidelines tell us mutual kendra .Since you have raised the question, let me see if I can locte the specific refernce

Regards,
Mahesh

[shiranffs]

.

[chavitarun]

AD does not take over MD
but AD is a more practical time window on which to make the forecast
regards[/quote]

respected shilpaji
namaskar

in one of the books written by an author Mr. Jangir , it was mentioned that we must forget about
Mahahdasha after its own antra . then we should see results only by various AD,s.
because in long dasha of venus or saturn , they will not give the results of Venus or saturn for all the
years of mahadasha.

whether this logic hold good or requires modification.
your views are solicited

regards

[shilpa]

Hi Shilpa and Anilesh

Yes, there was a typing a mistake.

I am born under GMT 7.5 hrs East in 1962. Only in 1st Jan 1983 did Singapore adjusted its GMT to 8 hrs East to be in line with Hong Kong, Perth and Beijing.

Thus if you take Vimottari Dasa from the Moon (and not Ascendant) I indeed was born under Mahadasa Mars and Antardasa Jupiter. Mars would be in the 10th Bhava and Saturn in the 7th Bhava in the Rasi chart. Yes, I do have extremely good family support and very good family environment right up till now even when I am 49 years old. Any other details?

In the Navamsa chart, Mars becomes my 9th Bhava ruler and Jupiter my 5th Bhava ruler, so giving me royal status under Navamsa.

If you take Vimsottari from the Ascendant, my Mahadasa would be Saturn and Antardasa Mercury in the Rasi chart when I was born.

Saturn governs my 5th Bhava (and a Yogakaraka at that) in D-6 and Mercury governs my 9th Bhava in D-6. I am usually fortunate during the periods of Mahadasa Saturn and Antardasa Mercury as well. Problems simply cannot touch me!

In D-8 and D-30, Mercury and Saturn switch places with Saturn ruling my 9th Bhava and Mercury my 5th Bhava. These give me royal status under D-8 and D-30 and I interpret it as I come up tops in my problems - because D-8 and D-30 has something to do with the outcome of your problems. That is how I interpret them. Is that correct?

However, I place more emphasis taking Vimsottari from the Moon (than on the Ascendant) based on the above information, because I am always fortunate regardless of which dasa periods are operating (for Mars and Jupiter influences) but for Saturn and Mercury good effects to occur, their periods must be operating. Any opinions on this?

Thanks.

Warmest Regards
Hock Leong

Dear Khoo,

--yes we are all on the same page now....you were born under the 5/9 period.

--thx for confirming that you had a fortunate home/ parental/ upbringing.

--your 5th Lord of creativity, intelligence and intellect is Mars in his own house in the 10th...making 5th house and quite strong and hence it's signifciations in the field of creativity/ intellect/ good fortune and mastering scriputers/ spiritual Vidyas( studies)/ Mantras & Upasana quite strong.

--and not only that Mars is your strongest planet.....in Simhasanamsa in dasavarga group of higher charts.

--and not only that Mars sits in his own house, it's house of digbala, the 10th house......making it a strong 10th house. The material significations of the 10th hosue are strong in yuor chart, and especially honor/ recognitions in the Mars anatars.

--shani ruling your 7th and 8th is also strong in his own hosue not only at the Rasichart level but also in gopuramsa in dasavarga.And shani also rules your 10th house in Dasamsa, and is also in his own house in D10
Strong and successful career...maybe some kind of senior official in government.
You are blessed by a good, strong Me too, the Karak for learning and intelligence also in Gopuramsa, and a high Vimsopaka bala.

As shani transits to exaltation...in Libra this Nov, a strong phase of happiness at the home front, income from properties and comforts from various 4th house signifcations awaits you.

--Moon is probably the only weak planet ( realtively speaking) in your chart......leading you to over anxious, overly analytical, anxiety driven personality. If you are a believer in remedies, prayers, fasts on mondays, and keeping sea-shells by your bedside will help

--anyway fortunate foudnation throuhg birth in 5-9 period of a solid/ strong and blessed chart.

regards

[nits]

..

[rvenkats]

Shilpa-ji,
I am running Me (9th & 6th Lord) Dasa (Cp Lagna) and Ve my 5th Lord is in the 6th with Sa (Lagnadhipathi). Ke is with Me.
1. My Me/Ve Dasha was decent in that, at start of Ve AD I got a new job with a massive raise in salary and my financial position improved quite a bit. Got a new vehicle in that time too. No job or any other hassles majorly. In all very peaceful.

2.When Su AD came to play - lost my job and got another one quickly. So it was an OK period but travelled 100% .

3. So was my Mo AD where I got a better position/salary in the second part of the AD as the first was still a lot of travel but slightly less, Ma AD was relatively smooth,

4. Ra AD was with tension with an old boss but again a very good jump in career within 6 months of the AD - had some travel but was like 25%

5. Ju was a lot of tension and changed jobs 2 time but income was always there one way or the other. Again tension with boss during this period quite a bit in the early parts. I am in in Sa AD.

MY DOB is may 7, 1975 00:27 at Srirangam.

*) I am now running 9/1(and 2) and curious as to how that will generally pan out.

**) Ke is with Me in 5th. I am curious as to how his Dasa will be and

***) finally I will go into 5th/10th Lord Dasa of Ve. Both Me & Ve are of almost same strength around 7.5 Rupas average.

Can you provide some insights?

Regards,
Venkat

[shilpa]

respected shilpaji
namaskar

1 it is often written in astro books that dasha of Lagnesh, 5th & 9th house gives good results
even their lords are natural malefics

2. whether dasha of lords of 1, 5 & 9 give good result even if they are posited in dusthana or otherwise
weak or have malefic influence.

in many books only 1st point is written in general description but what about second point

regards

per the dictums from Madhya Parashari the 5-9 periods should bring fortune. The stronger those lords, the more fortunate those periods.

Your question is a good one...what if the 5/ 9 lords are malefic for the chart? I believe their periods will give mixed results at-least.

One of the resons for raising the thread is to get feed-back from various posters on their own experiences .

for example my 5-9 period was indeed fortunate, inspite of my 9th lord debilitated in Nvamsa...my father went on an assignment for 2 years to famous hillstations of Dehradun and mussorie and me and my brother as children for the first time got an opportunity to have several vacations in the then famous hill stations of Dehra, Mussorie and visit places like Badrinath, Rishikesh, Haridwar in summers as well as during snow-fall seasons in winter.

I believe inspite of troubles/ problems if the 5/9 lords are malefic....there will be still periods of immense joy that will form cherished memories in years to come.
However lets wait for more feedbacks

regards

[astro123]

interesting thread shilpa...I was myself born in my LL MD and 5th/10th lord YK Ad...Merc/Venus was also a good period ..Mercury is 6/9 lord and Venus is a first rate YK

[Khoo Hock Leong]

Thanks Shilpa for the wonderful analysis.

I would try to get some sea-shells to put on my bedside.

Warmest Regards
Hock Leong

[chavitarun]

respected shilpaji
namaskar

1 it is often written in astro books that dasha of Lagnesh, 5th & 9th house gives good results
even their lords are natural malefics

2. whether dasha of lords of 1, 5 & 9 give good result even if they are posited in dusthana or otherwise
weak or have malefic influence.

in many books only 1st point is written in general description but what about second point

regards

per the dictums from Madhya Parashari the 5-9 periods should bring fortune. The stronger those lords, the more fortunate those periods.

Your question is a good one...what if the 5/ 9 lords are malefic for the chart? I believe their periods will give mixed results at-least.

One of the resons for raising the thread is to get feed-back from various posters on their own experiences .

for example my 5-9 period was indeed fortunate, inspite of my 9th lord debilitated in Nvamsa...my father went on an assignment for 2 years to famous hillstations of Dehradun and mussorie and me and my brother as children for the first time got an opportunity to have several vacations in the then famous hill stations of Dehra, Mussorie and visit places like Badrinath, Rishikesh, Haridwar in summers as well as during snow-fall seasons in winter.

I believe inspite of troubles/ problems if the 5/9 lords are malefic....there will be still periods of immense joy that will form cherished memories in years to come.
However lets wait for more feedbacks

regards

Respected Shilpaji
Thanks again

Since Mahadasha is of longer period say for example 20 years for venus, during all the 20 years
result of Venus mahadasha will not accrue. It is said that after Venus anterdasha , the effects of anterdashas of other planets will be felt & one must forget about mahadahsa.

on the other hand it is said that first antra of any mahadasha ( i.e.venus anter in venus mahadasha)
is not good( even or sama). then how the result of venus will be felt.

pl. enlighten.

[shilpa]

Respected Shilpaji
Thanks again

Since Mahadasha is of longer period say for example 20 years for venus, during all the 20 years
result of Venus mahadasha will not accrue. It is said that after Venus anterdasha , the effects of anterdashas of other planets will be felt & one must forget about mahadahsa.

on the other hand it is said that first antra of any mahadasha ( i.e.venus anter in venus mahadasha)
is not good( even or sama). then how the result of venus will be felt.

pl. enlighten.

Dear chaviatrun,
Please look at this thread that explains my POV on the relationship between Dasa and anatardasa...regards

http://www.lightonvedicastrology.com/ph ... &start=125

[mannu21]

Respected Shilpaji
Thanks again

Since Mahadasha is of longer period say for example 20 years for venus, during all the 20 years
result of Venus mahadasha will not accrue. It is said that after Venus anterdasha , the effects of anterdashas of other planets will be felt & one must forget about mahadahsa.

on the other hand it is said that first antra of any mahadasha ( i.e.venus anter in venus mahadasha)
is not good( even or sama). then how the result of venus will be felt.

pl. enlighten.

IMO that MD sets the status/position one would enjoy during the period depending upon the condition of Dasha lord and good PD or AD makes one enjoy it to fullest (if MD is strong) and weak PD or AD can give some stress/problem but if MD is strong one would eventually overcome all problems.

I may be wrong and would request to be corrected

[shilpa]

interesting thread shilpa...I was myself born in my LL MD and 5th/10th lord YK Ad...Merc/Venus was also a good period ..Mercury is 6/9 lord and Venus is a first rate YK

dear astro,
thx for the feedback...yes indeed you were born in sat-Ve i.e 1-5
and Me-Ve would be your teengaed years in 5-9 period.

It is indeed emerging as a strong pattern that the combinations of trinal lords periods are good for the natives.

regards

[shilpa]

Dear Shilpa,

1) While looking at strength of planets, some write that:

A planet that is strong in D-1 and weak in D-9 or D-X; it will contribute to the overall strength (and conclusions) in D-1
But, the planet is weak in D-1 but strong in D-9 or D-X; that strength in divisional charts is applicable only for the area governed by D-9 and D-X…… it does not strengthen any way D-1…

If this is correct, while looking at issues in D-1, is looking for higher strength in dasavarga charts any way useful /benefit as far as D-1 is concerned?

Dear Mahesh,

how a planet will fructify overall in it's dasas and anatars will depend on it's strength in the group of higher charts.
Ho it will yield specific significations in say career will depend on D1 + D10 placements




2) To what extent the mutual placements (like 1/1; 2/12…) or friendship/enmity of MD and AD planets influence/modify the overall result?

the same analogy applies here.....if the prime-minster and hsi cabinet minsiter are friendly to each other......the result is great
if they are neutral...result is good/ average
if they are innimically placed, the result is less beneficial



3) A planet placed in 8 or 6 from a house or a house lord placed in 8 or 6 from its house affects the performance of the planet.... does it carry any weightage to final result?
as planet placed in 6 or 8 may not even aspect that house....

there are many ways of skinning the cat i.e taking the due weightage into account.

you can consider the relationship between the dasa and antara lords by taking their permanent + temporary relationship with each other.
we know for temporary relations planets are considered friend only if 2,3,4 or 10, 11, 12 from each other
regards

[sunny29031]

hi
29-3-1991
11-10 am
hyderabad

Here in this chart .... i would like to know the best period of the life ....as the

mahadasha of the trine lords ...all occur after years ,....


thanks....

[rvenkats]

Dear Shilpa,

I would greatly appreciate it if you can provide insights into my query.

Regards,
Venkat

[quote="rvenkats"]Shilpa-ji,
I am running Me (9th & 6th Lord) Dasa (Cp Lagna) and Ve my 5th Lord is in the 6th with Sa (Lagnadhipathi). Ke is with Me.
1. My Me/Ve Dasha was decent in that, at start of Ve AD I got a new job with a massive raise in salary and my financial position improved quite a bit. Got a new vehicle in that time too. No job or any other hassles majorly. In all very peaceful.

2.When Su AD came to play - lost my job and got another one quickly. So it was an OK period but travelled 100% .

3. So was my Mo AD where I got a better position/salary in the second part of the AD as the first was still a lot of travel but slightly less, Ma AD was relatively smooth,

4. Ra AD was with tension with an old boss but again a very good jump in career within 6 months of the AD - had some travel but was like 25%

5. Ju was a lot of tension and changed jobs 2 time but income was always there one way or the other. Again tension with boss during this period quite a bit in the early parts. I am in in Sa AD.

MY DOB is may 7, 1975 00:27 at Srirangam.

*) I am now running 9/1(and 2) and curious as to how that will generally pan out.

**) Ke is with Me in 5th. I am curious as to how his Dasa will be and

***) finally I will go into 5th/10th Lord Dasa of Ve. Both Me & Ve are of almost same strength around 7.5 Rupas average.

Can you provide some insights?

Regards,
Venkat[/quote]

[chavitarun]

respected shilpaji
namasakar
whether MD & AD will be good or bad in below cases :

1.when 5th or 9th lord is also dusthana lord besides being lord of good house.

2. when 5th or 9th lord , Mooltrikon rashi falls in dusthanas & other rashi falls in good house.

as it is said a planet owning two houses gives result of both the two houses it own during its MD & AD
the more result will be felt of mooltrikona rashi or house

regards

[shilpa]

hi
29-3-1991
11-10 am
hyderabad

Here in this chart .... i would like to know the best period of the life ....as the

mahadasha of the trine lords ...all occur after years ,....


thanks....

you are right.....for the subject under discussion i.e maha and anatara dasa s of trinal lords are a bit distant for you

[shilpa]

respected shilpaji
namasakar
whether MD & AD will be good or bad in below cases :

1.when 5th or 9th lord is also dusthana lord besides being lord of good house.

2. when 5th or 9th lord , Mooltrikon rashi falls in dusthanas & other rashi falls in good house.

as it is said a planet owning two houses gives result of both the two houses it own during its MD & AD
the more result will be felt of mooltrikona rashi or house

regards

if a planet in addtion to the a dustahn also own a MT, exaltaion or own house, then it gives only gives good effects that of the non-dustahn houses