Great insights Vivek sir. I have 4 questions:-
1.) Do we judge Dhan yogas from Moon and Bhava Chalit charts too?
2.) For the fixed lagnas, does the combination of Mercury & Jupiter in any non dusthana house is a dhana yoga?
3.) Do Dhana Yogas matter in Navamsha?
4.) Is there any Dhana Yoga in my chart given my planets change position in BC chart?
DOB:- 22/09/1993, 03:16 a.m, Asansol, W.B India.
11th house vital for Money?
Forum rules
READ Forum-Wide Rules and Guidelines NOTICE: OFFENSIVE POSTS WILL BE DELETED, AND OFFENDERS WILL HAVE ALL POSTS MODERATED.
READ Forum-Wide Rules and Guidelines NOTICE: OFFENSIVE POSTS WILL BE DELETED, AND OFFENDERS WILL HAVE ALL POSTS MODERATED.
Hi fluid2finance,
Good you see doing some new case studies. I want to give a example of my own chart for this case study..
1) combination of 5 or 9 with 1st in 1, 5, 9 or 10th (5 and 9 are Laxmi sthanas and most important)
I have this combination in 5th
2) 6, 8 and 12 being in another dusthana (ofcourse the vipreet rajyoga) this also contributes in cancelling negativities/ blockages and expenses and especially if happening along with 1 above, can make millionaires
I have this placement 8th & 11th lord jupiter in 6th house.
3) A very strong Venus is better than a very strong Jupiter for wealth. Though having both is best.
N/A
4) Combo of 2nd and 5th or 2nd and 9th in 5 or 9 or 1 or 10th is the best
I have this combination merc the 2nd and 5th lord with 9th & 10th sat in 5th house.
But the placements change in Bhava chalit, is this the reason i am not yet rich? Or because i am going through 11th house jupiter mahadasha which is in 6th, yet it is also the lord of 8th, 8th in 6th a vipareet rajyoga.
This jupiter is in own house in Navamsa. Who is the main culprit in my chart?
My details.
29/09/1982
22:15
Hyderabad
Good you see doing some new case studies. I want to give a example of my own chart for this case study..
1) combination of 5 or 9 with 1st in 1, 5, 9 or 10th (5 and 9 are Laxmi sthanas and most important)
I have this combination in 5th
2) 6, 8 and 12 being in another dusthana (ofcourse the vipreet rajyoga) this also contributes in cancelling negativities/ blockages and expenses and especially if happening along with 1 above, can make millionaires
I have this placement 8th & 11th lord jupiter in 6th house.
3) A very strong Venus is better than a very strong Jupiter for wealth. Though having both is best.
N/A
4) Combo of 2nd and 5th or 2nd and 9th in 5 or 9 or 1 or 10th is the best
I have this combination merc the 2nd and 5th lord with 9th & 10th sat in 5th house.
But the placements change in Bhava chalit, is this the reason i am not yet rich? Or because i am going through 11th house jupiter mahadasha which is in 6th, yet it is also the lord of 8th, 8th in 6th a vipareet rajyoga.
This jupiter is in own house in Navamsa. Who is the main culprit in my chart?
My details.
29/09/1982
22:15
Hyderabad
-
hiimnotcool
- Frequent Contributor

- Posts: 267
- Joined: 31 Aug 2010
What do you think about my 11th house, Vivek?
Lord of 11th exalted in 7th (movable lagna so obviously brings some trouble as well) . Mututal aspect by Lagna Lord (although it's saturn and mars, so that could be bad) and aspects 2nd lord. Saturn causes NBRY for 1st and 9th Lord as well. Sun in 5th Leo with full aspect on Moon in 11th Aquarius. From Moon, Saturn is 1st Lord exalted in the 9th.
I think 4 planets aspect 11th from Arudha Lagna with Jaimini aspects also which I heard was beneficial.
Aug, 29, 1985
22:33 (10:33PM)
Willows, California
Lord of 11th exalted in 7th (movable lagna so obviously brings some trouble as well) . Mututal aspect by Lagna Lord (although it's saturn and mars, so that could be bad) and aspects 2nd lord. Saturn causes NBRY for 1st and 9th Lord as well. Sun in 5th Leo with full aspect on Moon in 11th Aquarius. From Moon, Saturn is 1st Lord exalted in the 9th.
I think 4 planets aspect 11th from Arudha Lagna with Jaimini aspects also which I heard was beneficial.
Aug, 29, 1985
22:33 (10:33PM)
Willows, California
-
hiimnotcool
- Frequent Contributor

- Posts: 267
- Joined: 31 Aug 2010
thank you for the analysis!fluid2finance wrote:Hi Himnotcool,
A full moon in 11th (being lord of luxuries as 4th) is great
saturn as 11th lord exalted with full directional strength is great as long as the person is hardworking and good in maintaining relationships. Such a Saturn can give great rise in business with patience and good networking
Mars and jupiter opposition is good and typically when 2 debilitated planets aspect each other, they become good..sort of a neecha bhang yoga which is good for your 1st and 9th bhaavs
The person has to be careful not to hang on to the past too much and make emotional/ impulsive decisions (due to the 3 planets in 4th which are in enmical sign or debilitated sign)
Mars as a rule when in a Kendra in Cancer gives good results as long as moon is strong (depositor) and in your case it is
Mars is AK and in Pisces Navamsa which can make you a little emotional and sensitive by nature. A strong sun will give pride and intelligence to balance too much emotionality in things. Main lesson is to learn to let go of past relations and materialistic things and not to be overtly emotional
Thanks,
Vivek
i never knew that about two debilitated planets aspecting eachother. i also did not know that Mars in Cancer in a kendra was good as long as the Moon as strong. You can learn something new everyday with regards to astrology it seems.
you're right about the overly sensitive and emotional aspect. i'm definitely not a 'cry baby' or one to hold grudges but i am very stubborn and can be ruthless at times, probably because of aries rising. luckily mars in cancer and pisces d-9 that is probably tempered down to a degree.
thanks again, Vivek!
Hi f2f
I have 11L Venus debilitated in 10H conjunct exalted 10L hence neechabhanga. Also the dispositor of Venus, the 10L is exalted and in Pushkara Bhaga. Additionally, I have 9L in 9H from both lagna and moon. The 11L is further aspected by lagna lord Jupiter and 2L Saturn. Lagna lord is strong as he is in Paravatamsa in Dasavarga and also in Pushkara Navamsa. He is in 6H in Taurus in Rashi but moves to 5H in Chalit chart. As of now I have average finances and am unemployed / searching a job since Nov 2011. (6L of daily job = 11L = debilitated) So this may be a counter example? As an indicator of fluctuating finances, I have 2L in Parivartana with 8HL though the dasha of 2L is yet to start.
I have 11L Venus debilitated in 10H conjunct exalted 10L hence neechabhanga. Also the dispositor of Venus, the 10L is exalted and in Pushkara Bhaga. Additionally, I have 9L in 9H from both lagna and moon. The 11L is further aspected by lagna lord Jupiter and 2L Saturn. Lagna lord is strong as he is in Paravatamsa in Dasavarga and also in Pushkara Navamsa. He is in 6H in Taurus in Rashi but moves to 5H in Chalit chart. As of now I have average finances and am unemployed / searching a job since Nov 2011. (6L of daily job = 11L = debilitated) So this may be a counter example? As an indicator of fluctuating finances, I have 2L in Parivartana with 8HL though the dasha of 2L is yet to start.
Hi Fluid2finance(Vivek),
Interesting topic,, and my Venus as lord of 11th and 4th house placed in 9th house. Depositor of venus is Jupiter placed in 4th house causing parivarthana between Venus and Jupiter. However 11th house is Badhaka sthana as I am cancer ascendent. Could you please let me know how my 11th house or 11th lord impacts ? At the same time my Venus Mahadasha just started, Please see my Birth details below.
DOB: 19-May-1982
Time: 11:06 AM
Place: Vizianagaram, Andhra Pradesh
India.
Many Thanks,
sagiloyal.
Interesting topic,, and my Venus as lord of 11th and 4th house placed in 9th house. Depositor of venus is Jupiter placed in 4th house causing parivarthana between Venus and Jupiter. However 11th house is Badhaka sthana as I am cancer ascendent. Could you please let me know how my 11th house or 11th lord impacts ? At the same time my Venus Mahadasha just started, Please see my Birth details below.
DOB: 19-May-1982
Time: 11:06 AM
Place: Vizianagaram, Andhra Pradesh
India.
Many Thanks,
sagiloyal.
Vivek garu,
I would like to share my son's details .His 11 th Lord is in 11th house.He is doing A levels and good at studies.He got an offer to study medicine in UCL.
His details are
17th September 1996
17:44hrs
Place Vijayawada,India.
Regards
Lakshmi.
I would like to share my son's details .His 11 th Lord is in 11th house.He is doing A levels and good at studies.He got an offer to study medicine in UCL.
His details are
17th September 1996
17:44hrs
Place Vijayawada,India.
Regards
Lakshmi.
You may have something there fluid, though I'm not sure I agree with the Neecha Bhanga comment, but In my view the 11th lord has more do to with friends and older siblings than it has to do with money. However friends and relatives can be a very potent force in the gaining of wealth. This is why networking is considered so important in the business world.
My 11th lord is debilitated. I have had many problems with friends and the relatives on my mother's side of the family (11th lord is the moon). I also have no older siblings. In my life my friends have often eventually become my enemies also as I tend to attract false friends. I have had these problems with friends and mother's relatives my entire life despite the fact that my debilitated lord of the 11th is bhanga.
HOWEVER
the dispositer of my 11th lord is relatively strong. The result in my life has been that financially I do better than most people, but I have almost no friends and a very weak network circle.
So from my chart I would say that the lord of the 11th is the significator of friends, network and older siblings, but the dispositor of the 11th is what really tells of the person's finances.
Even as you say, Warren Buffet, who's 11th lord is also debilitated has also had many troubles establishing social connections in his lifetime, but his finances are excellent as the dispositor is exalted & conjunct the 11th lord.
My 11th lord is debilitated. I have had many problems with friends and the relatives on my mother's side of the family (11th lord is the moon). I also have no older siblings. In my life my friends have often eventually become my enemies also as I tend to attract false friends. I have had these problems with friends and mother's relatives my entire life despite the fact that my debilitated lord of the 11th is bhanga.
HOWEVER
the dispositer of my 11th lord is relatively strong. The result in my life has been that financially I do better than most people, but I have almost no friends and a very weak network circle.
So from my chart I would say that the lord of the 11th is the significator of friends, network and older siblings, but the dispositor of the 11th is what really tells of the person's finances.
Even as you say, Warren Buffet, who's 11th lord is also debilitated has also had many troubles establishing social connections in his lifetime, but his finances are excellent as the dispositor is exalted & conjunct the 11th lord.


