I cannot give you a clear cut answer to that. Question as to how benefic or otherwise a planet is without considering various other factors cannot be accurate.
1. Shad Bala
2. Lunar Paksha
3. Strength of the ascendant lord
4. Planets in vargottam
5. D9 and D10 and their nakshatra lords
6. D11 by Sheshadri Iyer
7. Nakshatra lords and pada lords.
8. Yoga at Birth
9. Strength of Rahu at Birth
10.Gender
11.Strength of the conjunction
Refer these two topics for more info
http://lightonvedicastrology.com/phpBB3 ... =4&t=17150
http://lightonvedicastrology.com/phpBB3 ... =4&t=17544
I have explained the basic rules all over this forum, the trinal lords behave well in their own houses whether they are functional benefic or neutral. But how powerful it is? If a certain combination forms a yoga, you have to check how powerful it is or what factors can break that yoga. If the birth chart doesn't meet the basic requirements, you cannot go into divisional charts and substantiate the yoga present there. I'm sorry but I cannot simply say anything just on the basis of planetary positions. Also I've explained it quite clearly in the first post that yogas don't make millionaires nor do planetary positions. It is totally inappropriate to ask such questions, no self made millionaire has went out and consulted an astrologer about whether he will become a millionaire, they all had a goal and had passion to derive the best of human ingenuity. Its not asking whether you will be rich, is it about how capable you are at something. If people don't struggle for wealth they won't know the value of it so they lose wealth quickly, so it all comes to your own will.
What Makes a Multi Millionaire Kundli
Forum rules
READ Forum-Wide Rules and Guidelines NOTICE: OFFENSIVE POSTS WILL BE DELETED, AND OFFENDERS WILL HAVE ALL POSTS MODERATED.
READ Forum-Wide Rules and Guidelines NOTICE: OFFENSIVE POSTS WILL BE DELETED, AND OFFENDERS WILL HAVE ALL POSTS MODERATED.
thanks a lot elipsis ji... tat was a convincing reply 
so frm tat i understand, D1 shoud indicate something good, only then we move to other Divisional charts.
if there is a negative look at the D1, then may be its vitality can be ascertained from related Divisional charts...
And I completely understood abt the yogas and its role in life!!
The reason i asked u the above ques was, in the case of marrige, if D1 isnt showing good aspects, people resort to D9 and D7 to see if good things are indicated to compensate the ill/ negative shown in the D1 chart...
I tout if the same method can be applied in other analysis also.
correct if am wrong sir
so frm tat i understand, D1 shoud indicate something good, only then we move to other Divisional charts.
if there is a negative look at the D1, then may be its vitality can be ascertained from related Divisional charts...
And I completely understood abt the yogas and its role in life!!
The reason i asked u the above ques was, in the case of marrige, if D1 isnt showing good aspects, people resort to D9 and D7 to see if good things are indicated to compensate the ill/ negative shown in the D1 chart...
I tout if the same method can be applied in other analysis also.
correct if am wrong sir
dear elipsis ji,
One more doubt in general is as follows$:
Say an eg here, 12th house in Trimsamsa is 5th frm 8th house thus talks on " getting recovered "
Saturn placement in this may tend to delay the process of recovery is what i perceive.
BUT if the same saturn happen to RETROGRADE, then will it result in faster recovery ??
I hope u understand the theme in this question, which tangents our discussion on the malefic and benefic effect of a planet
kindly advice sir
One more doubt in general is as follows$:
Say an eg here, 12th house in Trimsamsa is 5th frm 8th house thus talks on " getting recovered "
Saturn placement in this may tend to delay the process of recovery is what i perceive.
BUT if the same saturn happen to RETROGRADE, then will it result in faster recovery ??
I hope u understand the theme in this question, which tangents our discussion on the malefic and benefic effect of a planet
kindly advice sir
If a yoga- good or bad exists in D1 then you have to go in-depth and study how effective it is. This applies to all areas of life including marriage. Why would anyone jump into divisional charts first? Its not even appropriate to jump into divisional charts without even studying the birth chart in detail. There was this person saying - Jupiter in D9 in his own house makes people rich....
You are again asking the same thing about 12th house. Saturn behaves differently for instance in Revati Nakshatra, where he is faster than Mercury. Why does he do that? Its a dual sign, nakshatra lorded by Mercury, 100% sattvic in nature with depositor being Jupiter, so when a natural malefic stays there he want to get out of the house as quickly as possible so the native heals quickly. This depending on whether saturn is benefic in the chart. So it depends on so many factors.
You are again asking the same thing about 12th house. Saturn behaves differently for instance in Revati Nakshatra, where he is faster than Mercury. Why does he do that? Its a dual sign, nakshatra lorded by Mercury, 100% sattvic in nature with depositor being Jupiter, so when a natural malefic stays there he want to get out of the house as quickly as possible so the native heals quickly. This depending on whether saturn is benefic in the chart. So it depends on so many factors.
As of Dec 2015 I am no longer active on this forum. If you have any questions related to my topics you can contact me via email by clicking on my username. I very much enjoyed contributing on this forum.
-
YogiYugesh
- Contributor

- Posts: 115
- Joined: 22 Oct 2012
.........................................
Last edited by YogiYugesh on 22 Dec 2016, edited 1 time in total.
1हनुमान2अंजनीसुत3वायुपुत्र4महाबल5रामेष्ट6फाल्गुनसखा7पिंगाक्ष8अमितविक्रम9उदधिक्रमण10सीताशोकविनाशन 11लक्षमणप्राणदाता12दशग्रीवदर्पहा
Hi elipsisji,
Thanks for all valuable information you provide.
I wanted to find out if there are any windfall gains/sudden gains like lottery, inheritance in my chart. Can we predict the timing of these gains. My DOB: 4th May, 1974, 4:55 pm in Surat Gujrat. Is business more suited for should I just stick to the current job. Your help will be greatly appreciated.
Thanks.
Thanks for all valuable information you provide.
I wanted to find out if there are any windfall gains/sudden gains like lottery, inheritance in my chart. Can we predict the timing of these gains. My DOB: 4th May, 1974, 4:55 pm in Surat Gujrat. Is business more suited for should I just stick to the current job. Your help will be greatly appreciated.
Thanks.



