Do you consider panch mahapurush yoga from moon too?

[devian]

Respected astrologers,
Based on your practical knowledge, do you consider pancha mahapurush yoga if it is happening from the moon in a chart?
How do you consider the strength of the yoga if the planet change its house in bhava chalit chart? For example Saturn moving to Scorpio from Libra in bhava chalit even if it is in Kendra from the lagna?

[Dr Neeraj]

Dear Devian
I will share only my views.
I feel MP Yoga shd be seen from Moon too and if the planet is moved in Chalit chart, then certainly its effect will be reduced.
God bless you

[devian]

Thank you so much sir, for your valuable inputs.
But, sir in case an exalted or planet in own house change to Kendra house in bhava chalit, what conclusion you are likely to make?

[Dr Neeraj]

Dear Devian
If in the chalit chart, the planets are shifted to kendra then its better results shd be expected.
God bless

[devian]

Thank you very much sir. You are so kind.

[vedicvishal]

Dr Neeraj Sir
Thanks for the insight about this.
If we see PMP yoga from lagna but that yoga is not from moon, should we still consider it or no?

thanks

[Dr Neeraj]

Dear VV
Yogas from Lagna indicates physical events while Yogas from Moon indicates mental inclinations.
So, my view is that we shd consider yogas from both lagna and Moon. Both have their own meanings.
Regards

[Dr Neeraj]

A video by Nitin Kashyap https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hWjuO7eHTXM
Worth watching for the better understanding of Chalit chart.