Deepakji,
While you are reading this, can you please take a look here: http://www.lightonvedicastrology.com/ph ... 18&t=10806
Wonder if this is a case of abhukta moola?
People born on Amavasya
Forum rules
READ Forum-Wide Rules and Guidelines NOTICE: OFFENSIVE POSTS WILL BE DELETED, AND OFFENDERS WILL HAVE ALL POSTS MODERATED.
READ Forum-Wide Rules and Guidelines NOTICE: OFFENSIVE POSTS WILL BE DELETED, AND OFFENDERS WILL HAVE ALL POSTS MODERATED.
-
ChandraLagna
- Site Administrator

- Posts: 2428
- Joined: 17 Apr 2011
--भज गोविन्दं... भज गोविन्दं...गोविन्दं भज, मूढमते --
With Regards,
ChandraLagna
With Regards,
ChandraLagna
Arun ji, This Bhava / Chalit Chakra business will one day land us in trouble . P.V.N.R. ji is clearly against this concept . He has sound logic . What do we do with the divisional charts ? I say, how do we assign the planets in relation to the Nakshatras ? See my chart .
26 04 1973
00 26
Mangalore
normal placement - Shani is in the 6th house . But J hora shows the Nakshatra as Mrigashira 1st pada . How can that be ?
Take budha. In the chalit chart ( Fron Asc ) budha is in Mesha . Yet J hora shows the Nakshatra as Revati 1st pada . What do we take to be the right Bhava ? . I suggest we stick to the normal divisions and refrain from the chalit chart . What say you ?
26 04 1973
00 26
Mangalore
normal placement - Shani is in the 6th house . But J hora shows the Nakshatra as Mrigashira 1st pada . How can that be ?
Take budha. In the chalit chart ( Fron Asc ) budha is in Mesha . Yet J hora shows the Nakshatra as Revati 1st pada . What do we take to be the right Bhava ? . I suggest we stick to the normal divisions and refrain from the chalit chart . What say you ?
Through hard work and spiritual practices, a person gets honor and dignity. The lazy one who puts in no efforts is like a fool who allows salt to be spilled on the wounds of his misfortunes. The idler depending only on fate, achieves nothing. - K.N.Rao ji
Arun, I have replied there . You are right. It is a case of Abhukta Moola Dosha . Moreover Ketu is in a bad state .Deepakji,
While you are reading this, can you please take a look here: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=10806
Wonder if this is a case of abhukta moola?
Through hard work and spiritual practices, a person gets honor and dignity. The lazy one who puts in no efforts is like a fool who allows salt to be spilled on the wounds of his misfortunes. The idler depending only on fate, achieves nothing. - K.N.Rao ji
-
ChandraLagna
- Site Administrator

- Posts: 2428
- Joined: 17 Apr 2011
Thanks for the Moola case!
On your chart, I am seeing Shani in 5th
Body NATAL Longitude Nakshatra Pada Rasi Navamsa
Lagna 2 Cp 14' 09.63" USha 2 Cp Cp
Sun - DK 11 Ar 56' 06.49" Aswi 4 Ar Cn
Moon - PK 12 Cp 23' 02.91" Srav 1 Cp Ar
Mars - AK 27 Cp 45' 20.29" Dhan 2 Cp Vi
Mercury - BK 18 Pi 58' 37.63" Reva 1 Pi Sg
Jupiter - MK 16 Cp 45' 13.43" Srav 3 Cp Ge
Venus - PiK 16 Ar 05' 37.25" Bhar 1 Ar Le
Saturn - AmK 24 Ta 25' 22.99" Mrig 1 Ta Le
Rahu - GK 17 Sg 41' 07.42" PSha 2 Sg Vi
Ketu 17 Ge 41' 07.42" Ardr 4 Ge Pi
Maandi 3 Pi 33' 46.07" UBha 1 Pi Le
Gulika 20 Aq 28' 17.66" PBha 1 Aq Ar
Bhava Lagna 13 Cp 48' 59.03" Srav 2 Cp Ta
Hora Lagna 16 Li 26' 05.09" Swat 3 Li Aq
When I do a Bhava, Kuja goes into 2nd. Other than that, i dont see Merc changing at all - it remains in Pisces!
On your chart, I am seeing Shani in 5th
Body NATAL Longitude Nakshatra Pada Rasi Navamsa
Lagna 2 Cp 14' 09.63" USha 2 Cp Cp
Sun - DK 11 Ar 56' 06.49" Aswi 4 Ar Cn
Moon - PK 12 Cp 23' 02.91" Srav 1 Cp Ar
Mars - AK 27 Cp 45' 20.29" Dhan 2 Cp Vi
Mercury - BK 18 Pi 58' 37.63" Reva 1 Pi Sg
Jupiter - MK 16 Cp 45' 13.43" Srav 3 Cp Ge
Venus - PiK 16 Ar 05' 37.25" Bhar 1 Ar Le
Saturn - AmK 24 Ta 25' 22.99" Mrig 1 Ta Le
Rahu - GK 17 Sg 41' 07.42" PSha 2 Sg Vi
Ketu 17 Ge 41' 07.42" Ardr 4 Ge Pi
Maandi 3 Pi 33' 46.07" UBha 1 Pi Le
Gulika 20 Aq 28' 17.66" PBha 1 Aq Ar
Bhava Lagna 13 Cp 48' 59.03" Srav 2 Cp Ta
Hora Lagna 16 Li 26' 05.09" Swat 3 Li Aq
When I do a Bhava, Kuja goes into 2nd. Other than that, i dont see Merc changing at all - it remains in Pisces!
--भज गोविन्दं... भज गोविन्दं...गोविन्दं भज, मूढमते --
With Regards,
ChandraLagna
With Regards,
ChandraLagna
Bossy , make the reference for the Bhava chart from the Ascendent . Its right now from the Moon . Shift it to Asc .
Through hard work and spiritual practices, a person gets honor and dignity. The lazy one who puts in no efforts is like a fool who allows salt to be spilled on the wounds of his misfortunes. The idler depending only on fate, achieves nothing. - K.N.Rao ji
Deepak,
By my calculations you are running Jup-Mer-Sun. For your recent venture profits looks to be moderate but there is a slight chance of being good too. However be careful, you may hit a roadblock when moon transits UBh. Its your natal pratyari tara, and transit Ketu and Sat both creating Nk vedha on it. Hope for the best.
swamykool
By my calculations you are running Jup-Mer-Sun. For your recent venture profits looks to be moderate but there is a slight chance of being good too. However be careful, you may hit a roadblock when moon transits UBh. Its your natal pratyari tara, and transit Ketu and Sat both creating Nk vedha on it. Hope for the best.
swamykool
It's better to rule in hell than to serve in heaven.
Good day sir,
GU-BU-SU ? What are your settings sir ?
anyways, thank you for the analysis sir. Hope I sail through this one .
Best regard's
deepak
GU-BU-SU ? What are your settings sir ?
anyways, thank you for the analysis sir. Hope I sail through this one .
Best regard's
deepak
Through hard work and spiritual practices, a person gets honor and dignity. The lazy one who puts in no efforts is like a fool who allows salt to be spilled on the wounds of his misfortunes. The idler depending only on fate, achieves nothing. - K.N.Rao ji
Topocentric is the culprit
. I shifted to Geocentric . Damn settings . I think J hora should show our settings in the basic info box . Right now it shows the Ayanamsha degree, but does not show the name . 
Through hard work and spiritual practices, a person gets honor and dignity. The lazy one who puts in no efforts is like a fool who allows salt to be spilled on the wounds of his misfortunes. The idler depending only on fate, achieves nothing. - K.N.Rao ji
Deepak,
Mer is deb, Mer's lord is deb. In the Nav there is a rashi exchange between Mer-Jup (enemies by PM). Be careful with your financial decisions in the Mer AD.
swamykool
Mer is deb, Mer's lord is deb. In the Nav there is a rashi exchange between Mer-Jup (enemies by PM). Be careful with your financial decisions in the Mer AD.
swamykool
It's better to rule in hell than to serve in heaven.
Arun, here is some info for you ,
P.V.N.R. Ji's comments on Bhavas . Page 162 - 12.8 Controversies
The stand of this book ( Vedic astrology - A integrated approach ) is very clear – each bhava (house) with respect to one reference can only be in one rasi. Even if Saturn is at 1º in Vi and lagna is at 29º in Le, we still say that the 1st house is in Le, the 2nd house is in Li and Saturn is in the 2nd house (though he is only 2º away from lagna). We do not recognize the house division methods of Porphyry and others in this book. Each rasi is a house and the 1st house is the rasi containing the reference. Readers will do well to follow Maharshi Parasara and ignore the creations and borrowings of later day Indian astrologers.
P.V.N.R. Ji's comments on Bhavas . Page 162 - 12.8 Controversies
The stand of this book ( Vedic astrology - A integrated approach ) is very clear – each bhava (house) with respect to one reference can only be in one rasi. Even if Saturn is at 1º in Vi and lagna is at 29º in Le, we still say that the 1st house is in Le, the 2nd house is in Li and Saturn is in the 2nd house (though he is only 2º away from lagna). We do not recognize the house division methods of Porphyry and others in this book. Each rasi is a house and the 1st house is the rasi containing the reference. Readers will do well to follow Maharshi Parasara and ignore the creations and borrowings of later day Indian astrologers.
Through hard work and spiritual practices, a person gets honor and dignity. The lazy one who puts in no efforts is like a fool who allows salt to be spilled on the wounds of his misfortunes. The idler depending only on fate, achieves nothing. - K.N.Rao ji
Deepak,
Yes, both Parashar and Varaha Mihir propounded one rashi - one House. The idea of Bhava chalit was created by an 8th or 9th CE astrologer named Shripati. In my experience Bhava Chalit only confuses things but it does clarify some issues when planets are at the very edge of a rashi. i.e. rashi sandhi.
swamykool
Yes, both Parashar and Varaha Mihir propounded one rashi - one House. The idea of Bhava chalit was created by an 8th or 9th CE astrologer named Shripati. In my experience Bhava Chalit only confuses things but it does clarify some issues when planets are at the very edge of a rashi. i.e. rashi sandhi.
swamykool
It's better to rule in hell than to serve in heaven.
Advice taken and noted loud and clear sir . Let me see how the Neecha Bhanga Raja yoga works .by swamykool » Thu Jun 16, 2011 1:04 pm
Deepak,
Mer is deb, Mer's lord is deb. In the Nav there is a rashi exchange between Mer-Jup (enemies by PM). Be careful with your financial decisions in the Mer AD.
Thanks a ton
best regard's
Through hard work and spiritual practices, a person gets honor and dignity. The lazy one who puts in no efforts is like a fool who allows salt to be spilled on the wounds of his misfortunes. The idler depending only on fate, achieves nothing. - K.N.Rao ji
-
R V RAMANAN
- Site Administrator

- Posts: 2879
- Joined: 18 Mar 2010
Dear Deepak,
This present plunge you have taken now is not much of a concern. You will easily be able to manage and come out of this risky venture with aplomb.
I am a bit concerned about your JU-ME-SA. Here both the MD & AD lords are in debility and the PD lord though being the lagna lord and placed in a trine is a avayogi for your chart. By Sept 3rd next year, Rahu will be directly transitting the avayogi point and at the same time will be aspected by the 12th lord JU & debilitated Ketu.
From the time Sun enters Aries (ie) mid-April to the time Mars, your badakesh leaves Libra ( around sept 30th ), any form of deep sea diving OR bungie jumping will get you into terrible trouble. See in this present venture you have not lost your pants. In that you will. So, my advise is any risk taking investment OR any other form of adventure should be ruled out after April 2012 till almost the end of the year.
Trust this helps.
Regards,
Ramanan
This present plunge you have taken now is not much of a concern. You will easily be able to manage and come out of this risky venture with aplomb.
I am a bit concerned about your JU-ME-SA. Here both the MD & AD lords are in debility and the PD lord though being the lagna lord and placed in a trine is a avayogi for your chart. By Sept 3rd next year, Rahu will be directly transitting the avayogi point and at the same time will be aspected by the 12th lord JU & debilitated Ketu.
From the time Sun enters Aries (ie) mid-April to the time Mars, your badakesh leaves Libra ( around sept 30th ), any form of deep sea diving OR bungie jumping will get you into terrible trouble. See in this present venture you have not lost your pants. In that you will. So, my advise is any risk taking investment OR any other form of adventure should be ruled out after April 2012 till almost the end of the year.
Trust this helps.
Regards,
Ramanan
-
Nitin21
Chaksji - You forgot Savana Settings.chaks wrote: Per Sri Sonu Sidhantha you are running Jup-Mer-Jup, does it change the picture a little?
-
R V RAMANAN
- Site Administrator

- Posts: 2879
- Joined: 18 Mar 2010
dear swamy,
power cut great nimitta
but any way will reply soon.
regards
ramanan
power cut great nimitta
regards
ramanan
-
Nitin21
I have been worried since the past 10 days as far as financials are concerned .
Bhai is it only coincidental that your Ketu AD in 6th started on 1st June
Bhai please avoid fridays for vehicular transactions or initiations as much as possible. Venus is combustI booked a container hauler last friday
Regards
Sonu
-
Nitin21
And i was talking about venus combustion beforeastroboy wrote:Arun ji,
In the case of faster planets, I think what you say makes sense .
Anu ji,
When a planet is debilitated in the 3rd, but if the 3rd lord is again debilitated, what about that ? More over, here the 9th is debilitated in the 3rd. Does that not give the person a lack of good luck when it comes to 3rd house matters ? As you well know, the 3rd house is the pivot of the upachaya houses . In my case 2 of the upachaya houses are debilitated. I have always felt that I have lacked the good fortune when I needed it most. I feel it strongly . Let me give you a instance . I had 3 dumpers with me . They were idle for 3 months. I sold 2 . 1 month later some people came to me and offered a huge contract for those dumpers . That was easy money and that too a unbelievable amount . Now instead of 3 I have sent only one to work . So I feel the 9th house needs to be unafflicted for all the other houses to function well . What is your opinion ?
( Let me add, I did not lose money in that sale . I did not make a huge profit , but I did not lose either . )
best regard's
Regards
Sonu
-
Nitin21
NAvamsa sir ..astroboy wrote:Chaks Sir, either ways its Guru all the way . Guru is also the 3rd lord . Budha is in the 3rd . Same story either ways .
Regards
Sonu
Deepakji, The Jupiter-Mercury period will answer this, till June 11, 2013. Personally I feel you will make a lot of money. regardsWhen a planet is debilitated in the 3rd, but if the 3rd lord is again debilitated, what about that ? More over, here the 9th is debilitated in the 3rd. Does that not give the person a lack of good luck when it comes to 3rd house matters ? As you well know, the 3rd house is the pivot of the upachaya houses . In my case 2 of the upachaya houses are debilitated. I have always felt that I have lacked the good fortune when I needed it most. I feel it strongly . Let me give you a instance . I had 3 dumpers with me . They were idle for 3 months. I sold 2 . 1 month later some people came to me and offered a huge contract for those dumpers . That was easy money and that too a unbelievable amount . Now instead of 3 I have sent only one to work . So I feel the 9th house needs to be unafflicted for all the other houses to function well . What is your opinion ?
( Let me add, I did not lose money in that sale . I did not make a huge profit , but I did not lose either . )
best regard's
Please seek as many opinions as you can from other learned member's on the forum as I might be completely wrong with the Analysis.
astroboy
Donator
Posts: 4087
Joined: 170310
A person should not be too honest. Straight trees are cut first and honest people are screwed first.
“Reasoning with a drunkard is like
Going under water with a torch to seek for a drowning man.”
“Reasoning with a drunkard is like
Going under water with a torch to seek for a drowning man.”
-
ChandraLagna
- Site Administrator

- Posts: 2428
- Joined: 17 Apr 2011
Swamicool's data is a good example:
House Start Cusp End Planets in it
7th 4 Ar 25' 51.26" 19 Ar 00' 46.35" 4 Ta 35' 27.73" Me, Ve, Sa
In Rasi, sani is in 8th, in House model, it shows up in 7th. Swamicool - you're the best judge of your own chart....
is sani completely 8-ish? Or a combo of 7th and 8th?
BTW, I'm sure you also realized the un-intended double entendre of the nimitta !

House Start Cusp End Planets in it
7th 4 Ar 25' 51.26" 19 Ar 00' 46.35" 4 Ta 35' 27.73" Me, Ve, Sa
In Rasi, sani is in 8th, in House model, it shows up in 7th. Swamicool - you're the best judge of your own chart....
is sani completely 8-ish? Or a combo of 7th and 8th?
BTW, I'm sure you also realized the un-intended double entendre of the nimitta !
--भज गोविन्दं... भज गोविन्दं...गोविन्दं भज, मूढमते --
With Regards,
ChandraLagna
With Regards,
ChandraLagna
Arun,
In my chart Shani will always be a combo of 7 & 8. Check again, Shani is the 7th & 8th L from the Moon. It has both been 7ish and 8ish
. But I don't think I am the best judge, my own chart confuses me no end. 
And kindly don't remind me about nimittas.
In my chart Shani will always be a combo of 7 & 8. Check again, Shani is the 7th & 8th L from the Moon. It has both been 7ish and 8ish
And kindly don't remind me about nimittas.
It's better to rule in hell than to serve in heaven.



