I wish this were true.Thanks for sharing this piece of information.Khoo Hock Leong wrote:Hi All
I just read recently that from Jaimini Sutras, that a natural malefic if debilitated, is a beneifc whereever it is placed (this is not the Parasara concept of a debilitated planet, benefic or malefic, in a Dusthana).
Best Regards
Hock Leong
Navamsas of Billionaires and Jupiter.
Forum rules
READ Forum-Wide Rules and Guidelines NOTICE: OFFENSIVE POSTS WILL BE DELETED, AND OFFENDERS WILL HAVE ALL POSTS MODERATED.
READ Forum-Wide Rules and Guidelines NOTICE: OFFENSIVE POSTS WILL BE DELETED, AND OFFENDERS WILL HAVE ALL POSTS MODERATED.
-
- Frequent Contributor
- Posts: 574
- Joined: 02 Jun 2011
-
- Frequent Contributor
- Posts: 7758
- Joined: 03 Jan 2009
Why do you say that? Is it because it does not apply to your chart?
-
- Frequent Contributor
- Posts: 7758
- Joined: 03 Jan 2009
Actually I always feel that debilitated planets are bad whatever the case. Most classics agree to that.
Example, in a past post, I mentioned that Saturn if debilitated, would make the person indolent. But the person is softer in temperament in that sense. He may also be able to coast by during bad periods.
I think planets strong would be better.
Thanks for rekindling my past thoughts on this point.
Example, in a past post, I mentioned that Saturn if debilitated, would make the person indolent. But the person is softer in temperament in that sense. He may also be able to coast by during bad periods.
I think planets strong would be better.
Thanks for rekindling my past thoughts on this point.
-
- Frequent Contributor
- Posts: 574
- Joined: 02 Jun 2011
No I don't have any debilitated malefic in my chart.Khoo Hock Leong wrote:Why do you say that? Is it because it does not apply to your chart?
My mercury is debilitated in Pisces and I remember you saying the debilitation of mercury gets cancelled by itself since it gets exalted in its own sign Virgo

Honestly that was true to some extent since Mercury didn't deprive me much of its significance during my mercury MD .
I am happy that people who have a debilitated malefic in their charts will not be much affected by its malefic results. Hence I wished it to be true.
-
- Frequent Contributor
- Posts: 7758
- Joined: 03 Jan 2009
It is true to a certain extent that natural malefics in debilitated signs do bring a modicum of benefits as explained earlier with the Saturn example.
BUT functional lordship of a planet, whether natural benefic or natural malefic, requires a planet to be strong.
So all in all it is still better to have a planet to be strong, even natural malefic, and that means being in their own, exaltation or Moolatrikona sings in the case of natural malefics. Friendly signs may not be be strong enough to hold the natural maleifc and to keep it in check.
Note also for exaltation of planets, the dispositor must be strong. If not the exaltation planets can do more harm than good, especially in the case of a natural malefic.
And also the dictum of a natural malefic in a sign with strength works best when the natural malefic is placeed in a kendra since natual malefics and kendras both have connotations of strength. It spurs the achievement of the native and also brings luck to a certain extent (natual malefics must be well placed).
BUT functional lordship of a planet, whether natural benefic or natural malefic, requires a planet to be strong.
So all in all it is still better to have a planet to be strong, even natural malefic, and that means being in their own, exaltation or Moolatrikona sings in the case of natural malefics. Friendly signs may not be be strong enough to hold the natural maleifc and to keep it in check.
Note also for exaltation of planets, the dispositor must be strong. If not the exaltation planets can do more harm than good, especially in the case of a natural malefic.
And also the dictum of a natural malefic in a sign with strength works best when the natural malefic is placeed in a kendra since natual malefics and kendras both have connotations of strength. It spurs the achievement of the native and also brings luck to a certain extent (natual malefics must be well placed).
-
- Newly Registered User
- Posts: 4
- Joined: 30 Aug 2016
Hi my name is nilesh and in my navamsa chart I have Venus and Jupiter and Saturn conjunction in Pisces
Could you please predict my future and what will be the effects of this conjunction in my future life.
DOB: 17/12/1983
Time: 02:45 am
Place: pune
Thank you in advance.
Could you please predict my future and what will be the effects of this conjunction in my future life.
DOB: 17/12/1983
Time: 02:45 am
Place: pune
Thank you in advance.
-
- Newly Registered User
- Posts: 4
- Joined: 30 Aug 2016
Hi,
Anyone from the forum, could you please reply to my post send on 30th Aug 16.
Thank you.
Regards,
Nilesh.
Anyone from the forum, could you please reply to my post send on 30th Aug 16.
Thank you.
Regards,
Nilesh.
-
- Newly Registered User
- Posts: 4
- Joined: 30 Aug 2016
Hi
Can anybody from the forum please reply to my cost.
Curious to know about the effect of this conjunction in my navamsa chart.
Can anybody from the forum please reply to my cost.
Curious to know about the effect of this conjunction in my navamsa chart.
-
- Newly Registered User
- Posts: 4
- Joined: 30 Aug 2016
Hi
I am waiting for the answer to my question raised below. Can anybody from the forum answer to my below query
I have Venus and Saturn and Jupiter conjunction in Pisces in my navamsa chart. What will be its effects in my future life.
I am waiting for the answer to my question raised below. Can anybody from the forum answer to my below query
I have Venus and Saturn and Jupiter conjunction in Pisces in my navamsa chart. What will be its effects in my future life.
-
- Contributor
- Posts: 75
- Joined: 12 Jan 2017
Hi people,
I have an excellent question regarding navamsa which matches the current topic.
My Jupiter in sign of saturn I.e., Aquarius in d9 in 7th house. But saturn has parivathan yoga with mercury(lord of 2nd and 11th). What can I expect in the next few years.
Am I going to be super rich or super sick? ROFL. I can feel it's the latter as I am fairly skinny. Please look into my first post.
Check the link or click my id to see my first post here. I would like to gain knowledge and hope to be able share with this forum in the near future with lots of confidence.
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=33866
I have an excellent question regarding navamsa which matches the current topic.
My Jupiter in sign of saturn I.e., Aquarius in d9 in 7th house. But saturn has parivathan yoga with mercury(lord of 2nd and 11th). What can I expect in the next few years.
Am I going to be super rich or super sick? ROFL. I can feel it's the latter as I am fairly skinny. Please look into my first post.
Check the link or click my id to see my first post here. I would like to gain knowledge and hope to be able share with this forum in the near future with lots of confidence.
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=33866
I am a certified gemologist and have worked in the jewelry industry in the past.. i did earn a living but not enough to secure a future. cancer ascendant, Jupiter in 8th house of saturn and saturn in 12th house with mercury in Gemini. DOB 9th june 1974, time 10.10 am, place Jamkhandi karnataka. can anyone suggest me a good line of profession which can help me earn a meaningful lifestyle? will appreciate all or any reply. Thanks
Dear Mr. Khoo and all other respected astrologers. I will highly appreciate if I can get a clarity on my financial scene through my life. I just want enough to lead a normal and meaningful life.. not aspiring to bathe in diamonds!!!
Please reply..
Thanks
Please reply..
Thanks
My Jupiter is in Pisces in Navamsa, it is also my Amatyakaraka, conjoined with Atmakaraka(Vargottamma Venus exalted in Pisces), Sun and Moon(Putra Karaka). Since I am speaking from a Jaimini Perspective, my Rahu is exalted in Gemini and Ketu in Sagittarius in Navamsa. In addition to this, my Saturn is Vargottamma in Capricorn.
Will appreciate if anyone has any insight to share. Could I have a career in politics or management down the line?
Will appreciate if anyone has any insight to share. Could I have a career in politics or management down the line?
Jupiter is the main karaka for the Wealth. Its placement in D1 chart itself should be well placed and should be aligning well with the ascendant lord, 10th lord and 9th Lord as well. Jupiter might play negative role for certain ascendants as well. Eg I have seen some Libra ascendant charts with Jupiter exalted in 10th house and no progress made by the person. Same seen in Capricorn ascendant as well. In such cases even if Jupiter gains good strength in D9 it might not bring the flow of wealth.
Once Jupiter has gained good position in D1 and well placed, then if it is gaining strength in Navmansha by either being vargottam (Same sign in Navmansh as that of D1) or placed in exalted in Navmansh that becomes an added advantage from the wealth accumulation, growth perspective.
Once Jupiter has gained good position in D1 and well placed, then if it is gaining strength in Navmansha by either being vargottam (Same sign in Navmansh as that of D1) or placed in exalted in Navmansh that becomes an added advantage from the wealth accumulation, growth perspective.
-
- Registered User
- Posts: 21
- Joined: 13 Jan 2025
Namaste Moodyji,
Here are 4 cases, I can share more where your conclusion of Jupiter being in Exalted, Mooltrikona, Own Sign in D9 does not hold true.
1. Arnault Bernard -Owner of All Major Faishon Brands - Net Worth : 172 Billion
5th March 1949, 17:00, Robiax , France. - Jupiter Debilitated in D9
2. Bill Gates - Microsoft
28 Oct 1955; 21:05, Seattle, Washington - Jupiter in Taurus in D9.
3. Lillian Bettencourt - the richest woman in the world at the time of her death, making her the fourteenth richest person in the world with a net worth of US$44.3 billion, as of the 2017 version of "The World's Billionaires." - 21 Oct 1922; 9 am, Paris, France - Jupiter in Scorpio in D9.
4. Mike Bloomberg : American politician, businessman, author and billionaire Net Worth
104 billion : Jupiter is Leo in D9 - 14 Feb 1942, 15:40, Birghton, Massachusetts
So I suppose we cannot take 1 factor and arrive at an conclusion.
Take this one :
Person X ; She orks as a maid in mu=y house for a salary of INR 12,000 a month, has not assets at all. 24 Sept 1994, 10:15 am, Naigaon, Assam,India. - Jupiter is in Pisces in 5th house of D9
Here are 4 cases, I can share more where your conclusion of Jupiter being in Exalted, Mooltrikona, Own Sign in D9 does not hold true.
1. Arnault Bernard -Owner of All Major Faishon Brands - Net Worth : 172 Billion
5th March 1949, 17:00, Robiax , France. - Jupiter Debilitated in D9
2. Bill Gates - Microsoft
28 Oct 1955; 21:05, Seattle, Washington - Jupiter in Taurus in D9.
3. Lillian Bettencourt - the richest woman in the world at the time of her death, making her the fourteenth richest person in the world with a net worth of US$44.3 billion, as of the 2017 version of "The World's Billionaires." - 21 Oct 1922; 9 am, Paris, France - Jupiter in Scorpio in D9.
4. Mike Bloomberg : American politician, businessman, author and billionaire Net Worth
104 billion : Jupiter is Leo in D9 - 14 Feb 1942, 15:40, Birghton, Massachusetts
So I suppose we cannot take 1 factor and arrive at an conclusion.
Take this one :
Person X ; She orks as a maid in mu=y house for a salary of INR 12,000 a month, has not assets at all. 24 Sept 1994, 10:15 am, Naigaon, Assam,India. - Jupiter is in Pisces in 5th house of D9
2. Bill Gates - Microsoft
"28 Oct 1955; 21:05, Seattle, Washington - Jupiter in Taurus in D9." As per Astro Databank the T.O.B is 10pm . I am sharing the link . https://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gates,_Bill
"28 Oct 1955; 21:05, Seattle, Washington - Jupiter in Taurus in D9." As per Astro Databank the T.O.B is 10pm . I am sharing the link . https://www.astro.com/astro-databank/Gates,_Bill