Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer

[anuradha]

As per him, the two planets [A and B] if A aspects B sign and B aspects A's sign, this phenomenon will be known as 'aspect exchange',e.g if Jupiter is aspecting Cancer and Moon is aspecting Pisces. I have never read this in classical text. I request all the member to test this concept by contributing such charts here with an event having any relation of aspect exchange. Looking forward for the cooperation from the members of LOVA.

[khushi]

Hello anuradha ji,
I am not knowledgeable enough to tell you the events, but I have the following sign aspects-
4 H Leo Sun aspecting 10 H aquarious
7 H Scorpio Saturn aspecting leo

[anuradha]

Re: Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer
Postby Sweenym » 13 Mar 2014, 00:24

Hello anuradha ji,
I am not knowledgeable enough to tell you the events, but I have the following sign aspects-
4 H Leo Sun aspecting 10 H aquarious
7 H Scorpio Saturn aspecting leo
Sweenym
Contributor
Contributor

Posts: 74
Joined: 13 Feb 2013, 14:01

4L Sun is aspecting the 10H but 10L Saturn is not aspecting the 4H, so aspect exchange is not applicable.Thanks for taking the interest in this research.

[khushi]

Anuradha ji, isnt 10L Saturn aspecting the sign of leo in 4th house as Saturn is in 7th house?
Hence, leo is aspecting aquarious and saturn aspecting leo.

[anuradha]

Re: Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer
Postby Sweenym » 13 Mar 2014, 09:19

Anuradha ji, isnt 10L Saturn aspecting the sign of leo in 4th house as Saturn is in 7th house?
Hence, leo is aspecting aquarious and saturn aspecting leo.

Kindly share your birth details.

[SuryaLagna]

As per him, the two planets [A and B] if A aspects B sign and B aspects A's sign, this phenomenon will be known as 'aspect exchange',e.g if Jupiter is aspecting Cancer and Moon is aspecting Pisces. I have never read this in classical text. I request all the member to test this concept by contributing such charts here with an event having any relation of aspect exchange. Looking forward for the cooperation from the members of LOVA.

I have the 8th lord aspecting the 7th house and 7th lord aspecting the 8th house

[sayu]

Hello
What will be the effect of aspects exchange if chandra and ketu from lagna, aspecting Rahu, Surya, Budha and Shukra in the 7th house. This combination of planets belongs to a person having a unsettled, weak career and poor financial position. DOB
;7/7/63;POB:Gorakhpur (UP);TOB:18:10 Hrs.
Regards

[anuradha]

I have the 8th lord aspecting the 7th house and 7th lord aspecting the 8th house

Kindly share your birth details.

[anuradha]

Code: Select all

Re: Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer
Postby sayu » 13 Mar 2014, 15:32

Hello
What will be the effect of aspects exchange if chandra and ketu from lagna, aspecting Rahu, Surya, Budha and Shukra in the 7th house. This combination of planets belongs to a person having a unsettled, weak career and poor financial position. DOB
;7/7/63;POB:Gorakhpur (UP);TOB:18:10 Hrs. 
Regards

Sir, Not applicable on your chart, I am looking the vacant houses aspected by the other planet. regards

[ashtalakshmi]

Anuradha madam

In my daughter's chart saturn from Gemini aspects Sagittarius and Jupiter from Leo aspects Aquarius .

So 10th lord aspects 8th house and 8th lord aspects 10th house .
Details : 22nd august 2004., vellore., 00.50 am

[anuradha]

Re: Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer
Postby ashtalakshmi » 13 Mar 2014, 19:29

Anuradha madam

In my daughter's chart saturn from Gemini aspects Sagittarius and Jupiter from Leo aspects Aquarius .

So 10th lord aspects 8th house and 8th lord aspects 10th house .
Details : 22nd august 2004., vellore., 00.50 am

YES,Its a prefect case. As per him Saturn will give the result of Jupiter and Jupiter will give the result of Saturn. Since I do not have any idea about this, I am just observing this to make some opinion.

[ashtalakshmi]

Re: Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer
Postby ashtalakshmi » 13 Mar 2014, 19:29

Anuradha madam

In my daughter's chart saturn from Gemini aspects Sagittarius and Jupiter from Leo aspects Aquarius .

So 10th lord aspects 8th house and 8th lord aspects 10th house .
Details : 22nd august 2004., vellore., 00.50 am

YES,Its a prefect case. As per him Saturn will give the result of Jupiter and Jupiter will give the result of Saturn. Since I do not have any idea about this, I am just observing this to make some opinion.

Fine madam, will wait to read your opinion .

[ranjan.75]

As per him, the two planets [A and B] if A aspects B sign and B aspects A's sign, this phenomenon will be known as 'aspect exchange',e.g if Jupiter is aspecting Cancer and Moon is aspecting Pisces. I have never read this in classical text. I request all the member to test this concept by contributing such charts here with an event having any relation of aspect exchange. Looking forward for the cooperation from the members of LOVA.

Anuradha Madam,

In my Chart Cancer Ascendant Jupiter in ninth house & mercury in third house aspect each other sign.
I was changed my job/Company : 10th September 2001 & still working, Stability in my Career.
DOB: 16th September 1975, Time 02.14.30 AM, Place, Devprayag, Tehri Garhwal, Uttrakhand (78E36, 30N15)

regard / Ranjan

[anuradha]

Anuradha Madam,

In my Chart Cancer Ascendant Jupiter in ninth house & mercury in third house aspect each other sign.
I was changed my job/Company : 10th September 2001 & still working, Stability in my Career.
DOB: 16th September 1975, Time 02.14.30 AM, Place, Devprayag, Tehri Garhwal, Uttrakhand (78E36, 30N15)

regard / Ranjan

Here two planets are aspecting each other from own house[Jupiter-Mercury] Saturn -Moon are in sign exchange. Kindly read my first post . regards

[SuryaLagna]

Kindly share your birth details.

...

[anuradha]

Postby SuryaLagna » 14 Mar 2014, 11:56

anuradha wrote:
Kindly share your birth details.



'Successful people dont have friends, they only have competitors and enemies'

Jupiter is aspecting Kumbha[7H] and Saturn is aspecting Meena[8H]. So kinldly check the anter dasha of Saturn[15-09-2009 onwards] and Jupiter[17-11-2008 onwards] and see result of exchange of Saturn and Jupiter. regards

[SuryaLagna]

Madam, I am yet to have any good experience with jupter aspecting the 7th house, although its a benefic aspecting the 7th house. Jup AD's and PD's have given me quite a lot of breakups in relationships, may be due to the fact that its the 8th lord aspecting 7th. Surprisingly, Sun sat period turned out better than sun jupiter, as far as personal relationships are concerned.

I am unable to come to a conclusion as to the exact result of exchange. Is saturn behaving like jupiter and vice versa?

Can I please request you to delete my birth details from the above post.

[anuradha]

e: Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer
Postby SuryaLagna » 14 Mar 2014, 15:41

Madam, I am yet to have any good experience with jupter aspecting the 7th house, although its a benefic aspecting the 7th house. Jup AD's and PD's have given me quite a lot of breakups in relationships, may be due to the fact that its the 8th lord aspecting 7th. Surprisingly, Sun sat period turned out better than sun jupiter, as far as personal relationships are concerned.

I am unable to come to a conclusion as to the exact result of exchange. Is saturn behaving like jupiter and vice versa?

Can I please request you to delete my birth details from the above post.

As per the theory, Saturn should give the result of Jupiter and vice versa. Only you can judge if this theory is working or not?

[Crystalpages]

e: Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer
Postby SuryaLagna » 14 Mar 2014, 15:41

Madam, I am yet to have any good experience with jupter aspecting the 7th house, although its a benefic aspecting the 7th house. Jup AD's and PD's have given me quite a lot of breakups in relationships, may be due to the fact that its the 8th lord aspecting 7th. Surprisingly, Sun sat period turned out better than sun jupiter, as far as personal relationships are concerned.

I am unable to come to a conclusion as to the exact result of exchange. Is saturn behaving like jupiter and vice versa?

Can I please request you to delete my birth details from the above post.

As per the theory, Saturn should give the result of Jupiter and vice versa. Only you can judge if this theory is working or not?

Anuradha ji,

I will try to share in english, what I have understood from that universal language that has incorporated other languages, and opinions differ, why she did so!

Jyotish is not in my lineage (I searched!) but it came to me when I was a nubile teenager! And so did snakes and kingly ones and a fascination for BIGGER CATS (Lions and Tigers) and also scorpions! Hornets always fascinated me and almost killed my elder brother and later on stung me too and then arrive BHRAMARI...?

Small children too came, nephews and nieces and then mine own and theirs and grand-children and YES many dogs and pillas of 'others'? BUT, one thing in all these fifty years since the beginning I have never come across! That shows up as the seventh one in your hindi-devnagri signature!

ALL are trainable, lovable, despite their mistakes that can be deadly in one lifetime, but do we have just ONE?

I always had a fear for cats and through observations, and I had a feeling of affection for dogs over cats!

For the past few years, my children had been trying to bring dogs and cats in my life and for the first time in my life I have been experiencing those two species. Dogs show love so readily that no one can resist their charm. But they stimulate the rhinencephalon (most primitive and ancesteral part of the sensing-brain, phylogenetically?) rather adversarily (!), while cats, unless coddled too much when they do not want that or care -- are where we learn about, or can about what is love...?

Sometimes, those seemingly inimical do teach us the best lessons and most useful for our personal growth and learning! Including planets etc that show up to be so in charts that all, readers and nativities equally seem to despise? And, hastily, recommend -- remedies...?

But, LEARNING: Was that not why we came for -- to this lifetime, and many-times?

Think about that!

Regards,

Rohiniranjan

[lovacrs]

As per him, the two planets [A and B] if A aspects B sign and B aspects A's sign, this phenomenon will be known as 'aspect exchange',e.g if Jupiter is aspecting Cancer and Moon is aspecting Pisces. I have never read this in classical text. I request all the member to test this concept by contributing such charts here with an event having any relation of aspect exchange. Looking forward for the cooperation from the members of LOVA.

Anuradha ji,

Here is one 15/Oct/1982 18:16, Bangalore. Sa is aspecting Aries and Ma is aspecting Aq. In July 2010 and Macrh 2012 there were short foreign travels.

[SuryaLagna]

As per the theory, Saturn should give the result of Jupiter and vice versa. Only you can judge if this theory is working or not?

I will have to watch the forthcoming Jupiter and Saturn PD's and AD's to come to a definite conclusion. Prima facie view is that there is some force in the theory as i cant ignore the problems faced (in personal life and relationships ONLY) during jupiter periods, although for Leo Lagna natives, jupiter is considered to be an auspicious planet. This is the position in Sun MD.

However, as far as Venus MD is concerned, Venus Jupiter period was better than Venus Saturn. So i have my eyes on Moon Jupiter vis a vis Moon Saturn to decide the matter.

Also my 4th and 9th lord aspects the 7th and the 6th and 7th lord aspects the 4th.

[anuradha]

Re: Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer
Postby lovacrs » 15 Mar 2014, 11:57

anuradha wrote:
As per him, the two planets [A and B] if A aspects B sign and B aspects A's sign, this phenomenon will be known as 'aspect exchange',e.g if Jupiter is aspecting Cancer and Moon is aspecting Pisces. I have never read this in classical text. I request all the member to test this concept by contributing such charts here with an event having any relation of aspect exchange. Looking forward for the cooperation from the members of LOVA.

Anuradha ji,

Here is one 15/Oct/1982 18:16, Bangalore. Sa is aspecting Aries and Ma is aspecting Aq. In July 2010 and Macrh 2012 there were short foreign travels.

Sir, Prefect case, in July 2010 he was under Rahu-Ketu-Venus[till 9th July] Rahu-Ketu-Sun[till 28th July] and Rahu -Ketu -Moon. Rahu-Venus-Moon[till 26th March 2012] and then Rahu-Venus-Mars. Rahu-Sat-Sat was from 19-11-2004, can test this theory.regards

[lovacrs]

Re: Late Sh S.K Mehta, a great astrologer
Postby lovacrs » 15 Mar 2014, 11:57

anuradha wrote:
As per him, the two planets [A and B] if A aspects B sign and B aspects A's sign, this phenomenon will be known as 'aspect exchange',e.g if Jupiter is aspecting Cancer and Moon is aspecting Pisces. I have never read this in classical text. I request all the member to test this concept by contributing such charts here with an event having any relation of aspect exchange. Looking forward for the cooperation from the members of LOVA.

Anuradha ji,

Here is one 15/Oct/1982 18:16, Bangalore. Sa is aspecting Aries and Ma is aspecting Aq. In July 2010 and Macrh 2012 there were short foreign travels.

Sir, Prefect case, in July 2010 he was under Rahu-Ketu-Venus[till 9th July] Rahu-Ketu-Sun[till 28th July] and Rahu -Ketu -Moon. Rahu-Venus-Moon[till 26th March 2012] and then Rahu-Venus-Mars. Rahu-Sat-Sat was from 19-11-2004, can test this theory.regards

Hmm ... We are using different ayanamshas and year definitions. I pointed out these events since I was getting Ra-Ke-Ma and Ra-Ve-Ma for the two events respectively. Mars lord of 1 and 8th in 8th is difficult to justify a 9th house event. Hence I thought it was the aspect exhcnage working. But then it could also be due to Ma being in Me's Nakshatra who owns 3rd. Anyways the dates of events were 12/7/2010 and 12/3/2012.
If you are looking for any specific class of events based on aspect exchange I will check and see whether I have any on record for the native.

[huien1]

Seems I have couple of aspect exchanges. Pisces lagna - Me aspects 8th while Ve aspects 7th. Sa aspects 5th while Moon aspects 12th - Dulakara or Fagan ayanamsa used.
Do we have to consider the house where the aspect exchange occurs or just the planet since most of the planets own two signs?

[meena77]

i have one exchange . Pisces lagna Me aspects 8th and venus aspects 7th..