astroboy wrote:by shilpa » Mon Aug 29, 2011 5:07 pm
astroboy wrote:
Shilpa Ji, I am happy you have tackled Budha in this chart, But you have not explained how a debilitated planet in the D9 came about to give good results.
you never asked that question
I still hold a planet in the Navamsha in debilitation is debilitated. But what about Shani. Shani is in the 9th house in debilitation. Please note that both Shani and Kuja are in Pushkaramshas. How has Shani delivered excellent results?
I don't think from the extent to which you have narrated the case there is any explanation that shani has given him good results.
Has shani given him good results ?
at the onset I mentioned that he is happily married and is lucky(6th and the 7th in the 9th). Shilpa ji, Shani is the 7th lord and is debilitated. more than 12 years of marriage. Shani as the 6th, a important Upachaya house, and as the 7th lord should have given trouble in married life. Yet the marriage is stable. More importantly, Shani as a debilitated 6th lord in the 9th should have destroyed all the 9th house significations. However that is not the case. Look at Kuja the dispositor. Kuja is again in Pushkaraamsha. This has boosted the 9th house significations a great deal.
Hello astroboy,
1) thanks for more details on the 1970 born Manglorean native......the entire focus in your initial post was on his 700 employees, wealth, real estate, multimillion USD etc.
yes shani is bad for him in Rasi and owning the house of marriage...but the Karak for Marriage Venus is very strong in rasi and in good amasabal in dasa varga charts.....so the Rasi negatitvity of of house of marriage is compensated for to a big extent...by the strength of Karak of marriage in rasi and dasavarga.
Further shani is in a friendly house placement in D9 and a good amsabala in dasavarga....compenstaing to some extent the debility in rasi.
so his good married life cannot be necessarily delineated to Pushkar Navamsa.
2) The chart of Sonali like-wise has many strengths using conventional analysis...such as 7th lord common with 12th and in Swkashetra ( i.e own house)....and the planet that is in highest amsabala in dasavarga. That alone is sufficient to give a good married life in foreign lands.
Further Jup is in MT in D9 and also the planet with highes amsabala in dasavarga along with L7/ L12 of Rasi.
3) The point here is that the examples charts put forward are good / strong on their own.....then it becomes difficult to delineate and attribute their successes to the placements of planets in the pushkara bhaag of a rasi.
the only conclusive way will be to find a set of rather average/ poor chart that does not promise much throuhg normal / convetional analysis...yet the native has risen significantly.
I appreciate your hard effort and very informative materials...on this subject...and I am sure our readers will also appreciate the need for above in italics for more conclusive delineation of the affects of Pushkara bhag placement of planets.
Wish you a good Day---S
1हनुमान2अंजनीसुत3वायुपुत्र4महाबल5रामेष्ट6फाल्गुनसखा7पिंगाक्ष8अमितविक्रम9उदधिक्रमण10सीताशोकविनाशन 11लक्षमणप्राणदाता12दशग्रीवदर्पहा