Whether to use exceptions or not for Arudha padas ?

For discussion on the Jaimini system: use of karakas, Jaimini aspects, chara dasha or other Jaimini dashas, etc.
Forum rules
READ Forum-Wide Rules and Guidelines NOTICE: OFFENSIVE POSTS WILL BE DELETED, AND OFFENDERS WILL HAVE ALL POSTS MODERATED.
Post Reply
qwert123
Contributor
Contributor
Posts:61
Joined:08 Jun 2015
Whether to use exceptions or not for Arudha padas ?

Post by qwert123 » 13 Dec 2015

I see most astrologers ( including sanjay rath ji , Narshima rao ji ) using exceptions when calculating Arudha padas as given by parashara - jhora default settings

http://www.saptarishisastrology.com/dow ... riesBW.pdf

But then the great KN rao ji says not to use exceptions

and then some people use exact longitude method


This gives 3 different Arudha lagnas with totally different results which makes it very confusing for us novices . I would like to request experts to share their experiences on this very basic and most crucial point

Thanks a lot



User avatar
Crystalpages
Frequent Contributor
Frequent Contributor
Posts:316
Joined:30 Jan 2014
Location:Rockcliffe

Re: Whether to use exceptions or not for Arudha padas ?

Post by Crystalpages » 13 Dec 2015

Please find and take up the chart of an individual you know well and/or you can follow-up with and get feedback from (avoiding in most cases, ones own chart).
Calculate using different recommendations.
See if there is one recommendation that fits observed reality better.

Sometimes more than one recommendation might seem to fit; which one fits better -- if can be determined will make your task easier.

Repeat the above test in more charts and see where the observed chips fall (as opposed to expected or recommended chips)

While not 100% guaranteed, often this process eliminates or at least reduces confusion, whether it is about a method of determination, or ayanamsha or any of the many *ties* that jyotish has or might have accumulated over time.
Rohiniranjan

qwert123
Contributor
Contributor
Posts:61
Joined:08 Jun 2015

Re: Whether to use exceptions or not for Arudha padas ?

Post by qwert123 » 14 Dec 2015

Thank you very much crystalpages ji for your reply :)

Post Reply